Advice from Cliff Clavin: A Sure Thing

This summer I went down a rabbit hole of the shows I grew up watching: LA Law, Golden Girls, MASH, ER, Cheers. The storylines and dialogue run from laughably quaint, to cringey, to gobsmacking. It's both a reflection of how quickly things have changed and how little we questioned our own certainty back then. And while this nostalgic rewatch is comforting at this particular moment in time (looking at you, President Bartlett), it also made me think about how each era takes its current circumstances and wisdom as universal truth. That's certainly true when it comes to money.

Here's a wild case-in-point I bet you didn't know about… In 1983, the U.S. Treasury Department commissioned an actual episode of Cheers — full cast, opening theme, the works — to sell U.S. savings bonds.

Seriously, look it up! The episode is called "Uncle Sam Malone." It never aired on TV. It only ever played at savings bond drives, which means someone, somewhere, decided the most persuasive way to get Americans to hand the government their money was to have Cliff Clavin talk about it at a bar.

And Cliff sells the hell out of it. He's just back from Tahiti, funded entirely by savings bonds, and he walks the gang through the pitch: a guaranteed return over 7%, tax advantages, safe as anything gets. By the end of the episode, even Diane (who announces she has a "keen sense" for finance) is sold. Sam, the least financially disciplined man in Boston, sets up a payroll savings plan for his own employees. "You've got to be stupid not to get in on these bonds," he says. "It's a sure thing."

A sure thing. Guaranteed. Safe.

And to be totally fair, that 7% wasn't a lie in 1983. It was true, for that moment, under those conditions. But it was sold as something bigger than a moment. It was sold as a law of nature. A one-size-fits-all, universal truth that needed no further exploration. Just like people believed that a single income buys a house. A pension guarantees security and comfort. Marry well and you're financially safe. Save 10% and you're set.

My point is that we're still following a set of universal truths without a whole lot of critical scrutiny. When someone watches old episodes of The Pitt, Ted Lasso, or Severance in 25 years, how will they reflect back on the things we take as gospel today? Because we're still being sold these truths, just not by Cliff Clavin. We're told that a high-yield savings account is where your money should sit. Or we're told the 50/30/20 rule that says to split our income into 50% for needs, 30% for wants, and 20% for savings. Or that you should definitely save at least three to six months' worth of essential living expenses to cover an unexpected job loss.

None of that is bad advice or wrong, exactly. It's that it's Cliff at the bar again, citing a confident number, delivered as a universal truth. But what it actually is, is a number that made sense for someone, under some conditions, at some point in time. The conditions are the whole thing. They're the part that gets left out when advice gets sold as a sure thing. And they're the part that's different for every single person reading this.

That's not a knock on rules of thumb. You need somewhere to start. But a rule of thumb is a snapshot, not a law. It was built with the average person in mind, not your specific life.

{Enjoy this blog post? Great! It was originally published in my monthly newsletter, “Cents & Sensibility.” If you’d like to subscribe to said newsletter, please reach out and I’ll add you to the list with all the other cool kids.}